Mother Earth Living

Avoiding Herbal Apocalypse: Keeping Herbs Alive

Even under optimal growing conditions, most herbs need regular maintenance and nurturing to fight the four horsemen:melting out, invasiveness, legginess, and seediness.
By Maureen Heffernan
April/May 2000
Add to My MSN

Illustrations by Susan Strawn Bailey

Content Tools

Related Content

Spring Favorites: The Good, the Bad and the Curly Chives

One of my favorite spring herbs chives comes in several different varieties. The uses for making her...

In The News: Cantaloupe Linked to the Deadliest Listeria Outbreak in a Decade

Get all the information about how to protect yourself from the latest listeria outbreak.

10 Things I Learned About Herbs in 2010

Every year—every day, in fact—we learn something new. During my time working for The Herb Companion ...

In the News: A Chinese Herb May Aid in Treatment of Autoimmune Disorders

The root of the blue evergreen hydrangea may aid in the treatment of autoimmune disorders.

Good grooming can enhance and prolong the beauty and productivity of herbs. Even in an informal garden, ungroomed plants look weedy and slovenly, not charmingly carefree: there’s a difference between a natural look and a natural disaster.

The four horsemen of the garden apocalypse are melting out, invasiveness, legginess, and seediness. These evil traits can make an unhappy mess of your herb garden.

Melting out

Many herbs, especially lamb’s-ears, thyme, and catnip, melt out (contract a fungal disease) under prolonged heat and humidity. Foliage and flowers turn brown or black and may die away from the center, leaving an unsightly bare patch.


Picture a 6-foot-4-inch adolescent who weighs 145 pounds—that’s legginess. Leggy herbs look skinny and have elongated stems that flop over readily. The plants may receive inadequate light due to excessive shade or overcrowding. The competition for light and soil nutrients often results in inferior flowers and oil production.


People described as having gone to seed have let themselves become unattractive or sloppy. The reference is to the scruffy appearance of many plants (especially annuals and biennials) after they have set seed. Having created offspring, these plants no longer need to impress potential pollinators or direct their energy into ripening seed.

To prevent seed formation in herbs grown for their foliage, pinch out (remove) flower buds. To prevent an overabundance of volunteer seedlings of such herbs as mallows, sweet Annie, and garlic chives, you can enjoy the flowers but cut them off before the seeds mature. Do encourage “seediness” in herbs grown for seed, such as coriander, dill, anise, and fenugreek.


Alan Greenspan’s description of the stock market as having a case of “irrational exuberance” could also describe the way herbs such as mint, lemon balm, borage, and tansy grow—swallowing their neighbors with their robust growth. When invasive plants migrate out of bounds, it’s not enough just to cut back foliage: you need to dig them up, roots and all. Some gardeners are able to limit their growth by planting invasive herbs in containers or in isolated beds.

Battling the horsemen

Fortunately, the horsemen of the garden apocalypse are more bothersome than lethal because they have one glaring weakness: no element of surprise. An experienced gardener can see them coming and take defensive measures: pinching or cutting back, dividing, and staking.

Pinching back

Pinching or snipping off an inch or two from the tip of a stem removes the stem’s active growing point. The result is to encourage the growth of lateral shoots, creating a bushier plant—important when an herb is grown for its foliage or is prone to flop.

Use your fingers, scissors, or hand pruners to nip off the stem tip as far as the first node (the point at which one or more leaves grows out of the stem). Pinching back should be done early in the growing season and may be repeated as needed.

Cutting back

Cutting back is a more severe form of pinching back that significantly reduces the size of a plant to promote the growth of new foliage, reduce sprawling, and stimulate a second flush of blooms. Cutting back also increases air circulation and light around plants, which may decrease their susceptibility to melting out.

Many gardeners fear cutting back plants—they’re so eager to get things to grow that it seems absurd to chop a plant in half. Fortunately, most gardeners get over their hesitations pretty quickly when they learn how cutting back improves vigor, shape, and flowering, as well as giving them a supply of herb clippings to dry or use right away.

Most nonwoody perennial herbs can be cut back close to the ground either in late fall or when new growth appears in early spring. Some gardeners in colder areas prefer to leave old stems in place over the winter to trap snow, which insulates the crowns from temperature extremes.

Use sharp hand pruners to cut stems, grabbing a clump of stems and cutting below them. For safety, wear heavy gloves and keep your eye on the blades.


Dividing plants takes time and muscle, but it’s the most important maintenance task for the long-term health and appearance of many perennial herbs. Whether to divide a plant depends on how robustly it’s increasing in breadth, whether it’s outgrowing its allotted space, and whether it’s dying out in the middle. A perennial plant can overcrowd itself when its offspring grow too close together. The resulting competition for soil nutrients and light can foster weak, leggy growth and reduce air circulation around the plants, which may predispose them to fungal disease. Overcrowded plants can be given a new lease on life by digging them up, discarding dead, diseased, and woody parts, and replanting a few healthy parts in amended soil.

Dividing is commonly done in the spring, although irises and daylilies are usually divided in summer after they have finished blooming. With a shovel, dig up the entire plant. If it’s not too overgrown, you may be able to pull the clump into two or more smaller clumps. More often than not, though, you’ll need to use a stout knife, spade, ax, or two pitchforks held back to back to separate the plant into manageable chunks. Work some organic matter into the soil and then reset a few healthy sections following the spacing recommended in the guidelines at right.


A little staking goes a long way to restore order to a chaotic garden. It’s even better, and loads easier, to install the stakes early in the season even if the plants don’t need it at the time. They’ll be much less conspicuous because the plant will have grown up around them.

Choose sturdy wooden stakes for tall-growing herbs such as mullein or foxgloves, tying the stems loosely with twine, raffia, or a strip of nylon stocking. Round metal hoops on legs work well for shrubbier,multistemmed plants such as dill and fennel, but Y-shaped branches pushed into the ground around the plant give a more natural effect.

Maureen Heffernan of Cleveland Heights, Ohio, is the director of education and public programs at Cleveland Botanical Garden.

Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next

Post a comment below.


Subscribe today and save 58%

First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Subscribe to Mother Earth Living!

Welcome to Mother Earth Living, the authority on green lifestyle and design. Each issue of Mother Earth Living features advice to create naturally healthy and nontoxic homes for yourself and your loved ones. With Mother Earth Living by your side, you’ll discover all the best and latest information you want on choosing natural remedies and practicing preventive medicine; cooking with a nutritious and whole-food focus; creating a nontoxic home; and gardening for food, wellness and enjoyment. Subscribe to Mother Earth Living today to get inspired on the art of living wisely and living well.

Save Money & a Few Trees!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You’ll save an additional $5 and get six issues of Mother Earth Living for just $14.95! (Offer valid only in the U.S.)

Or, choose Bill Me and pay just $19.95.